Forums

So, I watched a bit of X-Factor
...to see what all the hurrah-ing and boo-ing online is all about
Mon 22 Nov 2010 13:16
Bloody hell - I wasn't expecting what I got. I watched the first 2 acts on Saturday night - first up was Matt - who looked really self-conscious and uncomfortable in a vest and surrounded by hot dancers. He proceeded the grab his allocated Beatles tune by the throat and wrestle any musicality out of it by brute force. good job he'd ditched his sweater 'cos it looked like quite an effort.

Anyway next on was Cher who sang Imagine in such a way as to render it devoid of any emotional content. Whilst sat half way up a staircase.

So far so, so-so, but what genuinely had be agog was the way in which they judges then seemed to be implying that these people were genuine, one-of-a-kind superstars. I know it's cool to offer up faux shock at reality telly but seriously, it had me shouting at the telly (I now have an insight in to all the Facebook shouting I suppose lol ) - are we meant to think that the judges mean that stuff? Or actually, do they?

I turned over.
  • colda's Avatar
  • colda
  • Location: in the wrong place
  • Posts: 889
Mon 22 Nov 2010 13:35
as I mumbled last night between the swearing and calls for 'down with this sort of thing', they manage to give Stock, Aitken and Waterman credibility
Mon 22 Nov 2010 15:32
the other thing I found odd : why the pretence that it's the judge/mentor that's doing the song selection/styling/coaching ? I doubt anyone actually believes that.
Mon 22 Nov 2010 18:08
Reply to Post 72298 by TimO in So, I watched a bit of X-Factor the other thing I found odd : why the pretence that it's the judge/mentor that's doing the song selection/styling/coaching ? I doubt anyone actually believes that.


I think you're giving the general public a bit too much credit.
Mon 22 Nov 2010 18:58
I've got £20 on Wagner to win at 33/1. I laughed my fookin' head off last night : )
__________________________
WWW.MYSPACE.COM/LYDIATWENTY

WWW.MYSPACE.COM/CHARRCJ


WWW.PUTTYFOOT.COM


Yes...that is my new girlfriend : )

Yesterday is history and tomorrow is another day